info@nnpc.nl+31 (0)50 534 32 11
    • Dutch
    • English
    • German
    • About NNPC
      • The best solution for our members and clients
      • Our specialists
      • Worldwide network
      • History
      • Working at NNPC
    • Products and services
      • Mutual insurance
      • Fixed Premium
      • Other insurances
        • Inland shipping
        • Marine insurance
      • Risk check
    • News and publications
      • Publications
      • News
      • Newsletter
      • NNPC downloads
    • Contact
    Search
    START TYPING AND PRESS ENTER TO SEARCH
    • About NNPC
      • The best solution for our members and clients
      • Our specialists
      • Worldwide network
      • History
      • Working at NNPC
    • Products and services
      • Mutual insurance
      • Fixed Premium
      • Other insurances
        • Inland shipping
        • Marine insurance
      • Risk check
    • News and publications
      • Publications
      • News
      • Newsletter
      • NNPC downloads
    • Contact
    Search

    Responsibility for loading operations and demurrage in cases of cargo damage (inland shipping)

    Published on 4 years ago

    Recently, the Court of Antwerp rendered judgment in a case we had been handling since March 2018. It concerned contamination of a cargo of liquid fertiliser on board an inland vessel, pursuant to which the receivers had refused to take delivery of the cargo. After a long delay, the vessel was finally discharged a month after arriving in the discharge port.

    The cargo had been loaded in Antwerp under the supervision of the shipper and their surveyor. During the negotiation of the Charterparty terms, the owner had clearly informed the charterers that the cargo tanks would not be cleaned but only ventilated based on the previous cargoes carried on board. In light of the fact that the owner had clearly described the condition of the holds and this had been accepted by the charterer, the responsibility for the suitability of the holds to transport the cargo in question had passed to the charterer.

    As a significant cargo claim had been filed against the owner, we conducted an extensive investigation into the cause of the contamination. It turned out that there was contamination right from the start of the loading operations and the shipper and the surveyor were aware of this, however they decided to continue loading the cargo. The court determined that the master reasonably assumed that the shipper knew what they were doing given that he had been clear in advance about the condition of the holds and they were represented by a surveyor. Unfortunately, it turned out that the information about the condition of the holds had gotten stuck somewhere in the chartering chain. However, the court concluded that this did not take away from the fact that the shipper had decided to continue loading despite the fact that contamination had already been detected.

    In addition to the cargo damage, a considerable amount of demurrage had been accrued by the owners. The charterers had rejected this claim on the basis that the shipowner was responsible for the contamination and was therefore not entitled to recover his loss of time. At the end of last year, we already wrote an article (available on our website here) about the right to claim for demurrage in the event of cargo damage.

    In its judgment, the Court of Antwerp ruled that the owner could not be held liable for the contamination as he had complied with the obligation to provide information about the condition of the holds in advance. In addition, it was the responsibility of the shipper, who knows his cargo best, to judge whether his cargo can be loaded on board the ship and to ensure that the loading proceeds properly. The judge ruled that the owner was entitled to full payment of the demurrage, given that even if the owner had been (partly) responsible for the contamination, the receivers should have taken action to unload the ship earlier and to mitigate their damages.

    Previous Post
    Temporary PEC’s (Pilotage Exemption Certificates) for pilotage, must be obtained before 1 July 2021
    Next Post
    Additional work under a charterparty

    NNPC Newsletter

    Want to stay informed about the latest developments in risk management? Then sign up for the monthly NNPC newsletter:

    Sign Up

    Contact us

    Would you like to know more about one of our insurance policies, do the risk check or do you have another question? Contact us.

    Contact us

    Noord Nederlandsche P&I Club
    Rijksstraatweg 361
    9752 CH Haren (Groningen)

    Phone: +31(0)50 534 321 1
    E-mail: info@nnpc.nl

    PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

    • Mutual insurance
    • Fixed Premium insurance
    • Marine insurance
    • Inland shipping insurance
    • Risk check

    GO DIRECTLY TO

    • Contact
    • Find ships
    • Find correspondents
    • News and publications

    NEWSLETTER

    I would like to receive the digital newsletter of NNPC.

    Sign up

    FOLLOW US ON

    © 2025 NNPC – All rights reserved | Colofon | Privacy and cookies |